Monday, January 24, 2011

Effective Courtroom Testimony, Part 4

Credibility: What you say and how you say it!

It's a fact of human nature that the veracity, the truthfulness of a statement, is assessed by not only listening to (or reading for that matter) words, but by evaluating the individual's non-verbal clues. These non-verbal clues include the person's appearance, such as the clothes he/she is wearing, and the person's demeanor, which includes their body language. If during the course of our duties we ask a suspect if he/she has any drugs in his/her possession, we watch very closely, even below the level of consciousness, how the person responds. A "no" by the person isn't accepted as fact! Even the United States Congress interviews witnesses in person, rather than reading written interrogatories. Physicians want to see the patient, rather than just reading the chart.

And jurors, since they are human beings, will judge your credibility, your believability, not just on what you say on the witness stand, or what you wrote in the report, but on your appearance and demeanor. You should strive to use this fact to enhance your credibility.

As the dictum goes, first impressions are lasting. Even before you have taken the stand, the jury is evaluating your credibility, your fairness, your professionalism. Here are some basic guidelines for appearing in court. Some may seem quite humorous, quite self-evident. But trust me, officers do these things!

I know that different jurisdictions have different policies regarding courtroom attire, particularly regarding duty uniforms. I certainly do not intend to conflict with your department's policy. Wear what your department says to wear.

Regardless, however, I suggest you think of appearing in court as appearing for a promotional interview. If you wouldn't wear something for the interview, then it's probably not a good idea to wear it in court. Generally, dress conservatively and be well-groomed. Avoid fancy and ostentatious jewelry, big belt buckles, cowboy boots (unless you are in Texas of course!), NASCAR-style logo wear, and dark sunglasses. Avoid lapel pins and tie bars , such as those depicting pigs, handcuffs, and religious or political symbols, that may distract from your credibility. Finally, avoid jangling keys and jangling coins in your pockets.

In a future blog entry I will discuss the importance of your demeanor on the witness stand itself.

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Effective Courtroom Testimony, Part 3

The Pre-Trial Conference

Over the years, I've conducted a number of informal surveys of prosecutors and officers regarding testifying in court. The number one item on each group's "wish list" is for a bona-fide pre-trial conference. By "bona-fide," I mean an actual face-to-face sit-down in advance of the anticipated testimony date, and NOT the all-too-common two-minute discussion in the courtroom itself.

At the pre-trial conference, the parties should thoroughly discuss all aspects of the case. The officer should point out  possible weaknesses in the case, including omissions, errors, and inconsistencies in the report. The prosecutor may identify some potential defense challenges,including challenges to the officer's credibility.  The pre-trial conference is also an opportunity for the parties to build rapport and trust.

The prosecutor prepares the witness-officer for the trial by providing an overview of the direct examination process. Usually, the prosecutor will remind the officer to avoid jargon and slang while testifying, to maintain a calm demeanor (particularly when challenged by the defense), not to volunteer information when on the stand, to create charts or other visuals, and pick-up evidence as needed.

The pre-trial conference is a perfect opportunity for the officer to provide the prosecutor with an up-to-date copy of his/her curriculum vitae (resume), including a one-page summary.

Finally, it's a common tactic for a defense attorney to ask the officer if he/she had a pre-trial conference with the prosecutor. Do not hesitate to honestly answer this question. There is nothing wrong, and everything right, with having a pre-trial conference with the prosecutor. In fact, jurors expect it.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Effective Courtroom Testimony, part 1

Courtroom as Classroom

In my introductory post on this topic, I mentioned that the officer is a witness-teacher in court. To understand this concept, it's helpful to think of the courtroom as a classroom. And in this "classroom," the witness is the teacher. The "students" make up the jury. But unlike a college class that students enroll in, these "students" didn't ask to attend this "class." They were summoned to attend: told to set aside their work, their plans, in effect, their lives. Further, these students may be prohibited from asking questions of the teacher. They may even be told to not discuss what they learn from the teacher. In this courtroom as classroom analogy, the prosecutor is the designated student. It's almost as if the juror-students selected someone to ask all the questions of the teacher that they can't ask. As the designated student, the prosecutor asks questions from the students' perspective, sometimes asking the teacher-witness to explain. For example, "Officer, you used the term 'miosis.' Please explain what you mean by that term." What, then is the role of the defense attorney. Well, to a large degree, the defense attorney wants to testify! But he/she can't do that: only the witness can testify. So the defense "testifies" by making statements, and then asking the witness to agree with him/her. That's what we call leading questions. Example: "Officer, you don't know what my client's normal blood pressure is, right?" The judge is the last part of this courtroom as classroom analogy. The judge makes sure all the rules are followed, and decides disputes. The judge may even mete out discipline when the judge's rulings are challenged. So the judge can be thought of as a sports referee, or possibly as a school principal.

Thinking of the courtroom as a classroom provides some interesting challenges, and opportunities, for the officer-witness. I will discuss this in more detail in future posts.

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Effective Courtroom Testimony, Introduction

Testifying in court is stressful, as it should be. In my opinion, there are three primary reasons that testifying is stressful: (1) testifying is a form of public speaking; (2) for a police officer, testifying is in many ways the opposite of what he/she does every day - take control. In court, the officer cedes control to the attorneys and the judge, and primarily just answers the questions; and (3) testifying is serious business. A person's freedom may be at stake, and justice for the victim may depend upon the testimony.
 
I've heard many famous entertainers explain that they still get "butterflys" before taking the stage, even though they may have sang the same song thousands of times.  "Butterflys" in the stomach is a symptom of stress - good stress. If you don't feel some stress before taking the witness stand, perhaps you're not taking your responsibility as seriously as you should.
 
In future entries, I will discuss many different aspects of testifying in court, including the various types of questions that will be asked. I will also provide some "tips" in order to help you be a better communicator, actually teacher, in court.

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Effective Police Report Writing: Summary of 10 Tips

Here is a summary of the 10 Effective Police Report Writing Tips I have discussed in this blog. I occasionally will add to this compilation. In future blog entries I will provide similar suggestions regarding testifying in court.

Effective Police Report Writing Tips
#1: An officer is known by his or her reports.
#2: Juries want corroboration of the officer’s observations.
#3: Put something unique about the suspect/arrestee in your report.
#4: The Prosecutor reviews your report over a cup of coffee.
#5: It's impossible to accurately predict which case will go to trial.
#6: Spelling Counts!
#7: Statements are not necessarily admissions. Alibis aren't necessarily true.
#8: Avoid conclusionary language. Rather, describe thoroughly.
#9: Each arrest, each suspect, and each report is unique.
#10: Anticipate defense challenges and preempt them in your report.

Effective Police Report Writing, Tip #10

Anticipate defense challenges and preempt them in your report.

Anything you don't put in a report provides an opportunity for the defense to argue an alternative reality. In DUI cases, common defenses include: rising alcohol, a different driver (the passenger was driving), distractions during the Field Sobriety Testing phase, mouth alcohol, and more. A thorough report will preempt many of these typical challenges. For example, if the individual's alcohol level was rising, the person should be more impaired at the police station than at the arrest scene. If you believe "rising alcohol" may be a defense, then document how the individual is sobering up. If you anticipate an "It wasn't me driving" defense, document why you are certain that no one else was driving. 

A comprehensive, accurate, and thoroughly descriptive report (CAT) that anticipates defenses will prevent the defense from filling-in missing details in your report with a different version of the event. 

Friday, October 22, 2010

Effective Police Report Writing, Tip #9

Each arrest, each suspect, and each report is unique.
Just as no two snowflakes are identical, no two police reports, even for the same crime, should be identical. Not only do the names, locations and times change from investigation to investigation, the signs and symptoms exhibited (such as in a DUI/DRE case) by an individual will differ. In the old days (yes, I was there) police reports were handwritten or typed. With the advent of word processing computer programs in the 1980's, some officers were tempted to submit reports in which only the names, locations, and times were altered.  Every DUI arrest read the same way; every DUI arrestee exhibited exactly the same signs and symptoms. If your reports are of this "rubber-stamp" variety, it's only a matter of time before a defense attorney will use this to challenge your credibility in court.  Los Angeles Deputy City Attorney Rosemary Chavez, an ardent supporter of DUI and DRE officers, once remarked that (as the rock group Aerosmith sang) "the Dude looks like a lady." Rosemary was referring to her observation that rubber-stamped word processed reports sometimes confuse the gender of the arrestee - that John is all of a sudden referred to as Denise. Write your reports to enhance your credibility, not harm it.