It's impossible to accurately predict which case will go to trial.
Los Angeles Deputy City Attorney Rosemary Chavez has prosecuted Driving Under the Influence of Drugs defendants for twenty years. She also teaches in the LAPD's Drug Recognition Expert school, as well as in the related Impaired Driver Apprehension (IDA) course.
In Rosemary's experience, cases you would think would go to trial, often don't, usually because the defendant pleads to the charge. The converse is also true, in that it's not uncommon for apparently strong cases to unexpectedly go to trial. Rosemary's point is that your DUI arrest report should thoroughly document all the elements of the offense, including the three phases of DUI detection, and the drug influence evaluation, if any.
Rosemary also reminds officers that "You can't ever not do your job." A comprehensive, accurate, and descriptive report is part of your job.
Monday, August 23, 2010
Tuesday, August 17, 2010
Effective Police Report Writing, Tip #4
The Prosecutor reviews your report over a cup of coffee.
Tom Beadle, an Assistant Prosecuting Attorney with the Wayne County (Detroit) Prosecuting Attorney’s Office, reminds us that the prosecutor wasn’t at the arrest scene. Neither was the jury. Rather, the Prosecutor reviews your report in a climate-controlled office while sipping a cup of coffee. As Tom says, “I want to smell the person. And I want the jury to smell the defendant and hear the defendant. Your report should take me back to the scene.” Part of your job as a professional is to prepare a comprehensive, accurate, and descriptive report. The prosecutor, the judge, and the jury rely on you to take them back to the scene.
Tom Beadle, an Assistant Prosecuting Attorney with the Wayne County (Detroit) Prosecuting Attorney’s Office, reminds us that the prosecutor wasn’t at the arrest scene. Neither was the jury. Rather, the Prosecutor reviews your report in a climate-controlled office while sipping a cup of coffee. As Tom says, “I want to smell the person. And I want the jury to smell the defendant and hear the defendant. Your report should take me back to the scene.” Part of your job as a professional is to prepare a comprehensive, accurate, and descriptive report. The prosecutor, the judge, and the jury rely on you to take them back to the scene.
Saturday, August 14, 2010
Effective Police Report Writing, Tip #3
Put something unique about the suspect/arrestee in your report.
This tip comes from Ellen Sarmiento, a Supervising Assistant City Attorney of the Los Angeles City Attorney’s Office. Ellen has served as the supervisor of the Metropolitan Court in Los Angeles for many years. Located in downtown LA, Ellen’s staff has prosecuted DRE cases since the beginning of the DRE program.
Having an “independent recollection” of an incident enhances your credibility with the judge and jury. By documenting something unique about the person, your independent recollection may be triggered. For example, if the suspect was wearing colorful socks, or had a visible gold tooth, including these facts in your report will help you remember the facts of the incident.
This tip comes from Ellen Sarmiento, a Supervising Assistant City Attorney of the Los Angeles City Attorney’s Office. Ellen has served as the supervisor of the Metropolitan Court in Los Angeles for many years. Located in downtown LA, Ellen’s staff has prosecuted DRE cases since the beginning of the DRE program.
Having an “independent recollection” of an incident enhances your credibility with the judge and jury. By documenting something unique about the person, your independent recollection may be triggered. For example, if the suspect was wearing colorful socks, or had a visible gold tooth, including these facts in your report will help you remember the facts of the incident.
Wednesday, August 11, 2010
American Optometric Association Resolution supports DRE
Thanks to E. Robert Bertolli, O.D., of Connecticut, for sharing this with me. Dr. Bertolli has informed me that the resolution was unanimously passed by the House of Delegates on May 19, 2010.
American Optometic Association Resolution 1975
This is an excerpt from the Connecticut Association of Optometrists Newsletter, the President's column:
The American Optometric Association Resolution 1975 is an endorsement by the AOA of the Drug Recognition Expert program, which is a program used by highly trained police officers to detect people under the influence of drugs and alcohol. The program uses pupil and ocular motor tests as two of its testing components. Optometrists teach officers how the eyes react when under the influence of drugs or alcohol. The AOA is the first major medical community to endorse the program and this will be a major benefit for law enforcement and prosecutors. Resolution 1975 was a joint effort between the Connecticut and New Jersey associations.
I need to give Connecticut’s own Drs. E. Robert Bertolli and Robert Pannone credit for spearheading the concept. The CAO was the first Optometric Association to endorse the program after Dr. Bertolli presented the proposal to our Board of Directors twice last year. Shortly after learning of our resolution, New Jersey
followed our lead and passed a similar version. Our two State Associations then worked together for several months and countless hours in order to get this passed on a national level. This is expected to be a large public safety measure. This is a huge victory for us all and should make it much easier to introduce DRE testimony and evidence in court nationwide.
The AOA Endorsement could not have happened without the combined efforts of all of these folks, from consulting to face to face proposing and educating the AOA House of Delegates, and testifying for the Resolution Committee.
Optometrists
*****Connecticut Association of Optometrists (CAO)
E. Robert Bertolli, O.D. Board of Directors
Christopher L. Agro, O.D President
James Boccuzzi, O.D.President-Elect
D. Robert Pannone, O.D., Member
Lynn Sedlak, Executive Director
*****New Jersey Society of Optometric Physicians (NJSOP)
Michael J. Siegel, O.D.President
Charles H. Fitzpatrick, O.D. President-Elect
Harvey B. Richman, O.D., Immediate Past President
Maria S. Richman, O.D., Board of Directors
Jack E. Richman, OD, Member and Consultant
Howard Cooper,Executive Director
Law Enforcement Consultants:
Sgt. Kyle Clark, Florida State DEC Coordinator, Institute of Police Tech. & Management, Jacksonville, FL
Captain Terri Dioquino, Pinellas County Sheriff's Office, Largo, FL
Stephen Talpins, Chairman and CEO, National Partnership on Alcohol Misuse and Crime, Washington DC
Mark Neil, Senior Attorney, National Traffic Law Center,National District Attorneys Association,Alexandria,VA
Tom Page, DRE Emeritus
Congratulations everyone!!!!!!
American Optometic Association Resolution 1975
This is an excerpt from the Connecticut Association of Optometrists Newsletter, the President's column:
The American Optometric Association Resolution 1975 is an endorsement by the AOA of the Drug Recognition Expert program, which is a program used by highly trained police officers to detect people under the influence of drugs and alcohol. The program uses pupil and ocular motor tests as two of its testing components. Optometrists teach officers how the eyes react when under the influence of drugs or alcohol. The AOA is the first major medical community to endorse the program and this will be a major benefit for law enforcement and prosecutors. Resolution 1975 was a joint effort between the Connecticut and New Jersey associations.
I need to give Connecticut’s own Drs. E. Robert Bertolli and Robert Pannone credit for spearheading the concept. The CAO was the first Optometric Association to endorse the program after Dr. Bertolli presented the proposal to our Board of Directors twice last year. Shortly after learning of our resolution, New Jersey
followed our lead and passed a similar version. Our two State Associations then worked together for several months and countless hours in order to get this passed on a national level. This is expected to be a large public safety measure. This is a huge victory for us all and should make it much easier to introduce DRE testimony and evidence in court nationwide.
The AOA Endorsement could not have happened without the combined efforts of all of these folks, from consulting to face to face proposing and educating the AOA House of Delegates, and testifying for the Resolution Committee.
Optometrists
*****Connecticut Association of Optometrists (CAO)
E. Robert Bertolli, O.D. Board of Directors
Christopher L. Agro, O.D President
James Boccuzzi, O.D.President-Elect
D. Robert Pannone, O.D., Member
Lynn Sedlak, Executive Director
*****New Jersey Society of Optometric Physicians (NJSOP)
Michael J. Siegel, O.D.President
Charles H. Fitzpatrick, O.D. President-Elect
Harvey B. Richman, O.D., Immediate Past President
Maria S. Richman, O.D., Board of Directors
Jack E. Richman, OD, Member and Consultant
Howard Cooper,Executive Director
Law Enforcement Consultants:
Sgt. Kyle Clark, Florida State DEC Coordinator, Institute of Police Tech. & Management, Jacksonville, FL
Captain Terri Dioquino, Pinellas County Sheriff's Office, Largo, FL
Stephen Talpins, Chairman and CEO, National Partnership on Alcohol Misuse and Crime, Washington DC
Mark Neil, Senior Attorney, National Traffic Law Center,National District Attorneys Association,Alexandria,VA
Tom Page, DRE Emeritus
Congratulations everyone!!!!!!
Friday, August 6, 2010
Effective Police Report Writing, Tip #2
Juries want corroboration of the officer’s observations.
This tip comes from City of Minneapolis, MN Prosecutor Karen Herland. Karen, who served for many years on the IACP’s DRE Technical Advisory Panel (TAP), successfully prosecuted the landmark State v. Klawitter case. This was the first time that DRE testimony passed the scrutiny of a State’s Supreme Court.
Right or wrong, today’s juries don’t automatically assume that the police are infallible. Juries may not even believe that police officers always tell the complete truth. Therefore, your report should include the names and identifying information of others, particularly civilians, who witnessed the driving, the personal contact phase, the SFSTs, or other relevant aspects of the investigation. These witnesses may be valuable in corroborating your observations.
This tip comes from City of Minneapolis, MN Prosecutor Karen Herland. Karen, who served for many years on the IACP’s DRE Technical Advisory Panel (TAP), successfully prosecuted the landmark State v. Klawitter case. This was the first time that DRE testimony passed the scrutiny of a State’s Supreme Court.
Right or wrong, today’s juries don’t automatically assume that the police are infallible. Juries may not even believe that police officers always tell the complete truth. Therefore, your report should include the names and identifying information of others, particularly civilians, who witnessed the driving, the personal contact phase, the SFSTs, or other relevant aspects of the investigation. These witnesses may be valuable in corroborating your observations.
Thursday, July 29, 2010
Effective Police Report Writing, Tip #1
In July of 2010, I presented a workshop at the Pittsburgh IACP Impaired Driving Conference on Effective Police Report Writing. In preparing this workshop, I surveyed many prosecutors from throughout the country, asking them what they would like me to pass along to officers. I incorporated many of the prosecutors' suggestions into my presentation. I periodically will share a Report Writing Tip or Principle on this blog. So, without further adieu, here's the first principle:
An officer is known by his or her reports. As a supervisor who had to review arrest reports, I first looked for the reporting officer's name. I knew from experience that certain officers would invariably write complete, accurate, and thorough reports. In fact, prosecutors often make charging and trial decisions based on the completeness of the police report. An officer who has cultivated, through good reports, a reputation for thoroughness and accuracy is more likely to have his/her cases successfully prosecuted. Ask yourself, "What do I want my reputation to be?"
An officer is known by his or her reports. As a supervisor who had to review arrest reports, I first looked for the reporting officer's name. I knew from experience that certain officers would invariably write complete, accurate, and thorough reports. In fact, prosecutors often make charging and trial decisions based on the completeness of the police report. An officer who has cultivated, through good reports, a reputation for thoroughness and accuracy is more likely to have his/her cases successfully prosecuted. Ask yourself, "What do I want my reputation to be?"
Monday, July 26, 2010
Jack Oates honored at DRE Conference
Jack Oates (center of picture) was instrumental in the development of the formal DRE curriculum. In 1986, Jack, along with Bill Tower (on loan to NHTSA from the Maryland State Police) and Bill Nash of NHTSA, visited Los Angeles and monitored the LAPD DRE School. I instructed at this school. The faculty primarily consisted of LAPD officers. Jack, and the others, took notes and collected materials throughout the course. Jack refined our materials, and put them into the standard NHTSA curriculum format that is still used today.
On July 23, 2010, Jack was honored by the DRE Section of the IACP with a DRE Ambassador award. Jack is flanked by me on his right, and by Dick Studdard, the true father of DRE, on his left.
On July 23, 2010, Jack was honored by the DRE Section of the IACP with a DRE Ambassador award. Jack is flanked by me on his right, and by Dick Studdard, the true father of DRE, on his left.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

